Sign In »
Register Now!
Help
It's that time again, music lovers of the Palace. While previous tournaments have dubbed Jimi Hendrix the greatest rock guitarist and Chris Squire the greatest rock bassist, it's time to move on to the guys banging on the drums.
Nominations for the tournament will work exactly as they have previously: each TGP member may nominate up to 25 drummers, and you may designate a top 5. The top 5 makes seeding a little more precise: a nomination is worth 1 point, but a top 5 designation is worth 2 points. Note that you do not have to nominate 25 drummers, and your top tier does not have to contain five drummers. As always, feel free to edit your post after you've made it as more names come to you. This thread will stay open for awhile.
My ballott:
John Bonham
Neil Peart
Danny Carey
Mike Portnoy
----------------------
Ginger Baker
Nick Mason
Keith Moon
Mitch Mitchell
Ringo Starr
Bill Ward
Ian Paice
Nicko McBrain
Will update later.
Page 1 of 1
Greatest Rock Drummer of All-Time Tourney Nomination Thread
#2
Ngata_Chance 
- All Hail "Touchdown" Tommy Streeter.
-
- Group: Members
- Posts: 2,267
- Joined: 10-January 12
- Gender:Male
-
NCAA Team(s): Miami Hurricanes -
NFL Team: Ravens -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 10:31 AM
Nicko McBrain.
And where is the thread for rock guitarist because I disagree with Jimi Hendrix as the greatest rock GUITARIST.
And where is the thread for rock guitarist because I disagree with Jimi Hendrix as the greatest rock GUITARIST.
#3
SteVo
- Live Free or Die
-
- Group: Elite Prime+
- Posts: 20,711
- Joined: 07-July 08
- Gender:Male
- Location:Tampa, FL
-
NCAA Team(s): USF Bulls -
NFL Team: Eagles -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 10:38 AM
Ngata_Chance, on 10 June 2012 - 10:31 AM, said:
Nicko McBrain.
And where is the thread for rock guitarist because I disagree with Jimi Hendrix as the greatest rock GUITARIST.
And where is the thread for rock guitarist because I disagree with Jimi Hendrix as the greatest rock GUITARIST.
You're not the only one. Hendrix beat out Eric Clapton 13-9 in the final poll. If you scan through this forum (General Entertainment), you can see all the polls. Here's the general discussion/nomination thread, though: http://www.thegridir...y/page__st__40.
#4
RazorStar
- Miss Scarlet
-
- Group: Global Moderators
- Posts: 31,355
- Joined: 19-April 07
- Gender:Not Telling
-
NCAA Team(s): Auburn Tigers -
NFL Team: Broncos -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 10:55 AM
Mike Portnoy (Topic over)
Neal Peart
Danny Carey
Phil Collins
Keith Moon
All the noms I'm doing.
Neal Peart
Danny Carey
Phil Collins
Keith Moon
All the noms I'm doing.
Warning, Opinions may be included.
Credit to Phins4Life for the sweet Eric Decker sig
Credit to Phins4Life for the sweet Eric Decker sig
#5
Eefluxx
- Advanced Member
-
- Group: Members
- Posts: 1,232
- Joined: 29-August 09
- Gender:Male
-
NCAA Team(s): Alabama Crimson Tide -
NFL Team: Saints -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 11:01 AM
80's hair band days
Eric Carr (my personal favorite)
Alex Van Halen
Tommy Lee
Rick Allen (man had one arm and still found a way to play drums)
Charlie Watts (not really 80's drummer but he was the Rolling Stones drummer)
Most of the others I would mention have already been mentioned.
Eric Carr (my personal favorite)
Alex Van Halen
Tommy Lee
Rick Allen (man had one arm and still found a way to play drums)
Charlie Watts (not really 80's drummer but he was the Rolling Stones drummer)
Most of the others I would mention have already been mentioned.
#6
Bay
- lolRangers
-
- Group: Elite Members
- Posts: 6,644
- Joined: 14-March 10
- Gender:Male
-
NCAA Team(s): Ohio State -
NFL Team: 49ers -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 03:28 PM
Keith Moon
Carl Palmer
Ginger Baker
Terry Bozzio
Ian Paice
Dave Lombardo
Carmine Appice
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Dave Grohl
Carl Palmer
Ginger Baker
Terry Bozzio
Ian Paice
Dave Lombardo
Carmine Appice
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Dave Grohl
This post has been edited by BayAreaBomber: 10 June 2012 - 03:29 PM
#7
Zack_of_Steel
- The Blister Exists
-
- Group: Global Moderators+
- Posts: 11,840
- Joined: 13-May 07
- Gender:Male
-
NFL Team: Steelers -
Posted 10 June 2012 - 03:32 PM
John Bonham[/tournament]
Mathias said:
(18 September 2012 - 09:54 PM) Trent Dilfer has a Super Bowl ring. So we know there is no God.
ATL said:
(25 November 2012 - 09:31 PM) As a result of winning, whenever Zack's team beats mine. Whevener that may be. He may change my name for the following week.
#8
BwareDWare94
- RIP Levon Helm
-
- Group: Members
- Posts: 6,697
- Joined: 31-August 09
- Gender:Male
-
NCAA Team(s): North Dakota State Bison -
NFL Team: Cowboys -
Posted 11 June 2012 - 12:22 AM
One name I feel obligated to throw out there is Jason Bittner of Shadows Fall. He's a very subtle giant on the kit. Only when you listen closely and here the complexity of his fills, cymbal work, and double-bass work will you hear his genius. I really appreciate that. You have to really listen to him to understand just how complicated the things he's doing are.
I would like to express a sincere thank you to BoneKrusher for the badass sig and userbar.
#9
Crash3021
- Advanced Member
-
- Group: Members
- Posts: 237
- Joined: 30-December 10
- Gender:Male
- Location:West Caldwell, New Jersey
-
NFL Team: Giants
Posted 11 June 2012 - 11:40 AM
Buddy Rich
Terry Bozzio
Ginger Baker
Keith Moon
Ian Paice
Carmine Appice
Carl Palmer
Bill Bruford
Cozy Powell
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Mitch Mitchell
Mike Mangini
Virgil Donati
Tim Alexander
Bobby Jarzombek
Gene Krupa
Billy Cobham
Mike Giles
Dave Lombardo
Mark Zonder
Terry Bozzio
Ginger Baker
Keith Moon
Ian Paice
Carmine Appice
Carl Palmer
Bill Bruford
Cozy Powell
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Mitch Mitchell
Mike Mangini
Virgil Donati
Tim Alexander
Bobby Jarzombek
Gene Krupa
Billy Cobham
Mike Giles
Dave Lombardo
Mark Zonder
Thanks to BK for the awesome sig!
#11
monstersofthemidway
- Advanced Member
-
- Group: Elite Members
- Posts: 12,838
- Joined: 23-July 07
- Gender:Male
- Location:Great White North
-
NCAA Team(s): Michigan State -
NFL Team: Bears -
Posted 11 June 2012 - 02:15 PM
Neil Peart. Discussion over
The work of D mac. ^^^
[/quote]
#12
BoneKrusher
- Rock N Roll
-
- Group: Elite Prime+
- Posts: 15,136
- Joined: 08-August 07
- Gender:Male
-
NCAA Team(s): WVU and Texas -
NFL Team: Chiefs -
Posted 11 June 2012 - 03:14 PM
the one guy that i'd throw in there other than guys who've been mentioned would be Tommy Aldridge
HOUSTON: We Don't Have A Problem!
#13
Steelrain43
- Group: Members
- Posts: 96
- Joined: 13-June 12
- Gender:Not Telling
-
NFL Team: Unspecified
Posted 15 June 2012 - 07:34 PM
just so it is clear--I didn't read a single post on this thread, just read the title...
I bet he is mentioned..if he isn't, then shame on you...
neil peart..absolutely the most musical drummer on the planet,,you may be excellent at double bass parts doing 32nd notes at 160 BPM, but could you construct drum parts like peart does?? can you make your drumset fit a song like him?..
no, you cannot..
I bet he is mentioned..if he isn't, then shame on you...
neil peart..absolutely the most musical drummer on the planet,,you may be excellent at double bass parts doing 32nd notes at 160 BPM, but could you construct drum parts like peart does?? can you make your drumset fit a song like him?..
no, you cannot..
#14
Steelrain43
- Group: Members
- Posts: 96
- Joined: 13-June 12
- Gender:Not Telling
-
NFL Team: Unspecified
Posted 15 June 2012 - 07:36 PM
Crash3021, on 11 June 2012 - 11:40 AM, said:
Buddy Rich
Terry Bozzio
Ginger Baker
Keith Moon
Ian Paice
Carmine Appice
Carl Palmer
Bill Bruford
Cozy Powell
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Mitch Mitchell
Mike Mangini
Virgil Donati
Tim Alexander
Bobby Jarzombek
Gene Krupa
Billy Cobham
Mike Giles
Dave Lombardo
Mark Zonder
Terry Bozzio
Ginger Baker
Keith Moon
Ian Paice
Carmine Appice
Carl Palmer
Bill Bruford
Cozy Powell
Stewart Copeland
Bill Ward
Matt Cameron
Topper Headon
Jimmy Chamberlain
Gene Hoglan
Mitch Mitchell
Mike Mangini
Virgil Donati
Tim Alexander
Bobby Jarzombek
Gene Krupa
Billy Cobham
Mike Giles
Dave Lombardo
Mark Zonder
I am so impressed that somebody knew who mark zonder was!!!!..fates warning baby!.gotta love those prog drummers!
#15
SteVo
- Live Free or Die
-
- Group: Elite Prime+
- Posts: 20,711
- Joined: 07-July 08
- Gender:Male
- Location:Tampa, FL
-
NCAA Team(s): USF Bulls -
NFL Team: Eagles -
Posted 15 June 2012 - 07:38 PM
Steelrain43, on 15 June 2012 - 07:34 PM, said:
just so it is clear--I didn't read a single post on this thread, just read the title...
I bet he is mentioned..if he isn't, then shame on you...
neil peart..absolutely the most musical drummer on the planet,,you may be excellent at double bass parts doing 32nd notes at 160 BPM, but could you construct drum parts like peart does?? can you make your drumset fit a song like him?..
no, you cannot..
I bet he is mentioned..if he isn't, then shame on you...
neil peart..absolutely the most musical drummer on the planet,,you may be excellent at double bass parts doing 32nd notes at 160 BPM, but could you construct drum parts like peart does?? can you make your drumset fit a song like him?..
no, you cannot..
If this tourney comes down to anything but a Bonham vs. Peart final, it'll be a shame, honestly.
#16
monstersofthemidway
- Advanced Member
-
- Group: Elite Members
- Posts: 12,838
- Joined: 23-July 07
- Gender:Male
- Location:Great White North
-
NCAA Team(s): Michigan State -
NFL Team: Bears -
Posted 15 June 2012 - 07:47 PM
I don't know man Taylor Hawkins is also an amazing drummer. Dave Grohl as well. But yes I do think the final should be Peart vs Bonham
The work of D mac. ^^^
[/quote]
#17
Crash3021
- Advanced Member
-
- Group: Members
- Posts: 237
- Joined: 30-December 10
- Gender:Male
- Location:West Caldwell, New Jersey
-
NFL Team: Giants
Posted 15 June 2012 - 07:51 PM
Steelrain43, on 15 June 2012 - 07:36 PM, said:
I am so impressed that somebody knew who mark zonder was!!!!..fates warning baby!.gotta love those prog drummers!
Good to see another Fates Warning fan on the board, awesome band. And yeah, in general prog drummers are great.
Thanks to BK for the awesome sig!
#18
Steelrain43
- Group: Members
- Posts: 96
- Joined: 13-June 12
- Gender:Not Telling
-
NFL Team: Unspecified
Posted 16 June 2012 - 09:26 AM
Crash3021, on 15 June 2012 - 07:51 PM, said:
Good to see another Fates Warning fan on the board, awesome band. And yeah, in general prog drummers are great.
yeah, to be honest i am more of an older fan, than some of the new stuff that some memebrs are doing like redemption and osi..saw a matheos/arch video the other day, and i actually liked it..somehow it fit to hear arch singing like he does over something matheos wrote..ivory gate of dreams has been on e of my favs for a long time...paraells is a great album too, zonder shines on it, such depth..but I can't do without my no exit cd...LOL!...
and if it comes down to bonham/peart--sorry zep fans, this isn't a popularity contest, or it shouldn't be..peart can do anything bonham did, and a million things more he can't...maybe a million squared...
peart, in a landslide...I mean-huge landslide..no contest, unless you want popularity to count.but that's my take...
#19
Steelrain43
- Group: Members
- Posts: 96
- Joined: 13-June 12
- Gender:Not Telling
-
NFL Team: Unspecified
Posted 16 June 2012 - 09:40 AM
some excellent technicians also--of course mike portnoy, and his replacement mangini in dream theather...
notice some mentioned gene hoglan, dave lombardi...are we crossing into thrash/metal;/death/black metal as well?...
enter hellhammer then and also enter the original drummer from fear factory can't remember his name right off...his feet sound liek popcorn popping...
many of the european black/satanic norweigian bands have excellent drummers as far as double bass mastery..dimmu borgir and bands like those.
but like the above poster mentions, the prog drummers by nature of what they are asked to do, cover more ground and have to master just about every technique used from multiple genres often in the same song, from a 16th note quads double bass parts to a jazz sound instantly...play loud as hell, then quiet...
bands such as the melodic metal/prof types, shadows fall/sonotica artica/symphony x/dragonforce styles have them too...
we are blessed with such great musicians to be honest, as those mentioned in this thread...I leave out the old heros from my true generation, because they ahve already been mentioned in here...
but I am happy to see such a sports fanbase know their stuff when it comes to music..often all you see is sports fans mention popular bands drummers, because they don't know any better--if they are on the radio, they must be good kinda thinking...
nope.doesn't work that way, and that is sad..the best--are usually unpopular, because simple stuff sells, to simple people..nobody wants to hear technical music while smoking a joint and chasing a bimbo, it would make them nervous..LOL!...ok-done rambling.
notice some mentioned gene hoglan, dave lombardi...are we crossing into thrash/metal;/death/black metal as well?...
enter hellhammer then and also enter the original drummer from fear factory can't remember his name right off...his feet sound liek popcorn popping...
many of the european black/satanic norweigian bands have excellent drummers as far as double bass mastery..dimmu borgir and bands like those.
but like the above poster mentions, the prog drummers by nature of what they are asked to do, cover more ground and have to master just about every technique used from multiple genres often in the same song, from a 16th note quads double bass parts to a jazz sound instantly...play loud as hell, then quiet...
bands such as the melodic metal/prof types, shadows fall/sonotica artica/symphony x/dragonforce styles have them too...
we are blessed with such great musicians to be honest, as those mentioned in this thread...I leave out the old heros from my true generation, because they ahve already been mentioned in here...
but I am happy to see such a sports fanbase know their stuff when it comes to music..often all you see is sports fans mention popular bands drummers, because they don't know any better--if they are on the radio, they must be good kinda thinking...
nope.doesn't work that way, and that is sad..the best--are usually unpopular, because simple stuff sells, to simple people..nobody wants to hear technical music while smoking a joint and chasing a bimbo, it would make them nervous..LOL!...ok-done rambling.
Share this topic:
Page 1 of 1
1 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users
Toggle shoutbox The Mad Box
|
